Practice quiz: Being a reviewer

4 questions. Pick an answer to see if it is right. You can try as many times as you like. These are for practice: the final test has different questions.

1. 1.The first part of a good review is usually...

   the recommendationa short summary of what the paper claims and howtyposyour own papers
2. 2.Which is a helpful review comment?

   "The evaluation is weak.""Table 2 uses one seed and an untuned baseline; please report 5 seeds and tune the baseline equally.""I don't like it.""Reject."
3. 3.May you paste a manuscript you're reviewing into a public AI chatbot?

   Yes, alwaysNo: it breaks confidentiality, and many funders and publishers forbid itOnly the abstractOnly if anonymous
4. 4.After reading an author rebuttal that answers your concerns, you should...

   ignore itupdate your score if it's convincinglower your scorewrite a new review